Skip to Content

13 Best Online Jewelry Stores For Engagement Rings In 2022

So, you’re shopping for an engagement ring. Congratulations!

Whether you are getting ready to tie the knot, to replace your existing engagement ring, or simply to enjoy some new bling on your finger, this is an exciting adventure.

13 Best Online Jewelry Stores For Engagement Rings In 2022

Did you know you can shop and buy the perfect diamond engagement ring from right where you’re sitting? That’s right!

You don’t even need to leave your home. It can feel daunting shopping for something so important online without the ability to hold the ring in your hand and see it up close and personal for yourself.

But good news: online jewelry shopping is easier and safer than ever—especially if you shop in the right places.

So where is the best place to buy engagement rings?

1. Occasions Fine Jewelry

In addition to offering a wide selection of beautiful engagement rings, we’re especially proud of our jewelry warranty.

In fact, we think our lifetime warranty is the greatest warranty ever.

You can buy a ring here and have full confidence that we’ll have your back for years to come.

2. Blue Nile

A leader in the online jewelry world, Blue Nile has enjoyed 2 million customer celebrations since 1999.

Build your own ring online from scratch or view recently purchased engagement rings. 

3. Catbird

Offering a line of unique and beautiful rings, all jewelry at Catbird is made in their Brooklyn studio and is ethically sourced gold with conflict-free stones.

Famous shoppers at Catbird include Liv Tyler, Behati Prinsloo, and Lorde.

4. Etsy

While Etsy may not be the first place that comes to mind when you think about shopping for engagement rings, it truly has earned the honor as a best online jewelry store for engagement rings.

Especially if you’re looking for a unique or vintage-inspired engagement ring, be sure to check out what Etsy has to offer.

5. Gemist

Gemist is all about choice—and specifically, it’s all about putting the choice in your hands.

Create something unique with their incredibly intuitive and interactive design experience.

Bonus: Gemist has an amazing try-before-you-buy policy. At no additional cost, you can keep 3 rings for up to 2 weeks and then order the ring you love most.

13 Best Online Jewelry Stores For Engagement Rings In 2022

6. James Allen

Build your own engagement ring using any of the 200,000+ diamonds certified by the top grading laboratories.

Better still, see your diamond in 360° HD Superzoom, which is essentially the next best thing to being in the store and holding the diamond in your hand.

If you’re looking for fancy color diamonds, this is also a great place to look.

7. Kay Jewelers

Kay Jewelers has been in the business for a long time and knows a thing or two about engagement rings.

In addition to traditional engagement rings, they offer bridal sets, men’s engagement rings, and a create-your-own option.

Kay Jewelers has a feature on their website that enables you to easily shop according to your budget, so you’re not distracted by something out of your price range.

8. Littman Jewelers

With more than 140 stores nationwide, Littman Jewelers is a reliable place to shop and find engagement rings.

In 1998, Kroger (America’s largest grocery store) acquired the brand and has continued to offer an extensive variety of fine jewelry.

If you’re looking to buy an engagement ring online, definitely take a look at what Littman Jewelers has to offer.

9. Ritani

Ritani is a great place to find your dream ring.

Choose from popular engagement styles or create something entirely unique.

Ritani offers a helpful list of tools on their site to make planning and building your dream engagement ring an enjoyable process.

In fact, according to the site, they’ve “made getting to know your diamond easier than getting to know your in-laws.” What’s not to love about that?

10. Vrai

Vrai diamonds are simple and elegant, sustainably grown right here in the U.S. and they have no carbon footprint or mining.

They are then cut and polished in their own workshops by master craftsmen.

Truly elegant, they are worth your consideration.

13 Best Online Jewelry Stores For Engagement Rings In 2022

11. Whiteflash

Find inspiration and build your perfect ring or let Whiteflash create the ultimate diamond engagement ring for the love of your life.

If you’re looking for the best online jewelry store, definitely take a look at Whiteflash. 

12. Yadav

A family-owned business, Yadav seeks to do everything it can to make even the online shopping experience as luxurious as possible.

Create your own ring and enjoy a lifetime of unlimited upgrades.

13. Zales

Offering everything from exclusive designer brands to create-your-own custom-created rings, Zales has been in the business of helping customers find the dream ring for decades.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Eric Baker

Wednesday 28th of December 2022

Hi Kelly, This post is amazing but you can also list GemsNY in this article. Because they are also a reputed online jewelry store for engagement rings.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.