Formula Versus Breast Feeding for Newborns

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read my full disclosure policy here.

Having a child is one of the most important decisions you’ll ever make in your life.

There are so many considerations that expecting parents must think about or may worry over, especially if it’s their first child. Given this, it’s important to do your best to make all the ‘big’ decisions before your baby is born, including whether you’ll breastfeed or use formula.

Believe me, there’s more than enough to do once your bundle of joy gets home.

Once home, you’ll begin the fun of sleepless nights as a new parent - and that isn’t the time to be thinking about how you plan to feed your newborn!

This decision is vital because the first few months of nourishment decide your child’s future health, including whether his or her immune system will work efficiently. In fact, breast milk impacts infant immunity significantly and may even protect babies from the Coronavirus.

How are you supposed to make this life-altering decision while simultaneously coping with the daily stress of impending parenthood?

Fed is Best for Newborns, No Matter Which Option You Choose

Ensuring your baby receives enough nutrition goes beyond the ‘formula versus breastfeeding debate’, and must be satisfying in both quantity and quality. You can’t compromise the two; this isn’t negotiable.

Your child’s eating reflexes are taught from their first days of life, and this is imperative in the secretion of gastric juices and how the human body transforms food into energy after eating.

Whether using breast milk or formula, your baby must receive between 780ml to 200ml of milk each day from less than six months up to 18 months. 

You Can Choose to Breastfeed and Use Formula

Did you know that you can choose to use both options?

It’s true!

You can breastfeed and use formula, if needed. There’s no hard and fast rule that says you can’t!

However, it’s generally recommended to develop a breastfeeding routine first (for at least the first four weeks, if possible) before introducing bottle feeding to 1) maintain your breast milk supply and 2) ensure your baby doesn’t become ‘nipple confused’ or reject either option.

If you choose to exclusively breastfeed, your baby receives the optimal nutrition necessary for those first crucial weeks of development. After four months or so pass, it’s then a matter of choice whether you’d like to continue to nurse. If you’re undecided, it may help to speak with a lactation consultant to discuss your options. Every mom must make the right choice for her and her baby.

If you feel that your breast milk supply is a good enough alimentation for your baby - and confirm with your doctor that this is true - you can continue breastfeeding for as long as you feel comfortable doing so, up to two years or longer.

If you’re unable to breastfeed or choose to exclusively use formula, you don’t need to worry! While formula doesn’t provide the same antibodies or protection from illness as breast milk, FDA-trusted brands are well equipped to handle your baby’s nutritional needs and offer various vitamins and minerals to help baby grow.

In fact, some breastfed babies require supplementation with formula due to various issues like insufficient weight gain, latching problems, and prematurity. There’s no shame in the formula game – all that matters is your baby receives the nutrition he or she needs to thrive.

The Main Differences Between Breastfeeding vs Formula

Here’s a quick comparison to help you decide which option may be best for you and your little one.

Breastfeeding

  • Is free! No purchase or late-night store runs required
  • Offers infants different taste profiles based on mother’s food intake, making it easier to transition to solid foods
  • Is convenient – can be done anytime, anywhere, with no sterilization or bottles needed
  • Can promote higher IQ
  • Provides skin-to-skin bonding
  • Benefits mothers, too!
  • Ensures easy digestion for baby

Formula

  • Is convenient – can be done by anyone, including other family members or caregivers
  • Provides great flexibility for on-the-go moms
  • Requires less frequent feedings due to longer digestion time
  • Gives moms freedom to eat whatever they want! No need to worry about passing allergens or alcohol to their babies

As you can see, both offer positives that must be considered when making the decision to breastfeed or use formula.

Breastfeeding and Formula Feeding are Both Valid Choices

Of course, the final decision is up to you!

Take the time you need to consider all the aspects of both options and make an informed choice for you and your baby. If you’re still unsure, please consider reaching out to a professional lactation consultant for help.

13 Comments

  1. I cannot help but be frustrated by blogs like this one that continue to push the idea that formula can begin to stand up to breast milk. It's just not true. Formula is made by the body that made the baby & is the best for the baby--for more than the first few weeks of life! As a matter of fact, the world health organization recommends breast feeding for TWO years.

    I implore all expectant mothers to research why breast feeding your little is the very best start you can give you little blessing!

    1. **Correction--BREAST MILK is made by that body, NOT formula.

    2. Kristi, No one is saying that formula is better then breast milk. If your reading the article right it says "If you choose to breastfeed it important to do so for at least the first four months of the babies life. This way, the baby will have the optimal nutirition neessary for those first crucial weeks of development. After those 4 months pass, it’s really a matter of choice and how every mom feels it. If a mom feels that her breast milk will be a good enough alimentation for her baby and will also check a doctor on this matter, she can continue breast feeding a few extra months. If not, you don’t have to worry because formulas nowadays are really well equipped."

      I would NEVER say not to breastfeed, or formula is better. All I am saying is that it is the mother's choice. Some mother's feel after the first few weeks, that they just can't do it, they are tired..etc.. No parent should feel guilty or that they are not giving their baby what they need nutritionally if they decide to stop.

      I have 2 children and tried breastfeeding, but it didn't work out for me.. so I know that feeling of guilt..

      It is all about choice and what you think your baby needs.. If mother's want to breastfeed till 2 or 3 or longer, I applaud them, that is great from them and their child..

  2. My sister is due in October and She is still trying to,figure it out. So many factors also include money. If you do formula, you have to buy it and that does get expensive . But with breastfeeding, you need a pump, the bras, the cover ups, storage for extra milk, the pump pads, but you get the benefits for baby and mom.

    1. That is true Olivia. The benefits always outweigh everything else..

      1. I have breastfed three children without a pump or pads or anything special except a few nursing bras which cost me $6 each at Walmart :)

        1. That is great, it helps mom's to know that they don't need all the extras.. :)

  3. I totally agree with this! I think it is always a personal choice I myself could say a lot about this subject on how I feel but I think it was said well! And keep the posts coming! That's what a blog is all about! Good job!

  4. as a mother who breastfeeds i dont see how this post is pushing one way or the other. it is something that each mom need to figure out on there own and i would go with brestfeeding but there are issues where thats not possable . i would read up on everything and just do whats best for you. i also think before you go reading something more into this post then its read all of it. anyone with a brain would read the full post before commenting.

  5. I feel there's nothing wrong with a person expressing their opinion about how they feel about certain things. This is her opinion and she has a right to put it up on her blog. There's a lot of information on her blog about things in her life as well as her sharing recipes and other things. Thanks for all the information You provide to people who have no idea about a lot of things including your struggles with a Autistic child, there are few people who don't have an idea what that's like . GOOD JOB Keep it up.

  6. I agree with the post. My son was born three months early. Before that I decided not to breast feed which was my decision alone. What changed my decision was when my son was born way early and the dr told me that my body would produce the stuff in my milk to help fight off germs and viruses or basically anything in the nicu . I decided then to breast feed but my milk dried up and I couldn't produce no more . So with that said it is their choice to breast feed or not. I personally love this post because it makes new mothers to be or new mommies feel like what ever they choose was the decision.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *