When it comes to accordions, the two most prominent types are the button accordion and the piano accordion.
They both have their own benefits and drawbacks, but the vital questions that are glaring are;
Which is better for a novice?
What kind of accordion is the easiest to learn to play?
Based on previous results, following a brief learning period, the button accordion is far simpler to play than the piano accordion.
This is due to the fact that the buttons are smaller and more knitty spaced around the keys.
And with greater fingering possibilities, it is simpler to play many intervals and ranges in a short period.
While the learning process of a button accordion may be quite technical than playing a piano accordion – since remembering the buttons is more difficult than memorizing the piano keys on a piano accordion – the latter is particularly true if you already know how to play the piano, which is the case here.
On the flip side, the smaller buttons are great for the learning process and make it simpler to play the game.
Experienced button accordionists may span almost three octaves with a single stretch of their hands. On a piano accordion, this would be practically hard to do.
Piano Vs Button Accordion: Which Is Better?
These are still the two types of accordions that are often heard of.
Because there are fewer keys to push on the button accordion, it is simpler to play for beginners (which is after they understand how to use the buttons).
Furthermore, the keys are often used to symbolize two different notes. Apart from this, several of the keys are just for decorative purposes.
Because the buttons are closer together and easier to reach on the button accordion. It’s quite straightforward to perform transitions from low to high notes on the button accordion.
This reduces the possibility of you accidentally playing the out of tune note.
On the other hand, since the piano accordion includes buttons for practically every note, it might pose a bit of a challenge for novices to learn how to play.
It just means you must press multiple buttons to play the instrument, just as you would on a piano.
What is a Button Accordion, and how does it work?
The button accordion was the first form of an accordion to be developed.
It is majorly bisonoric (means it’s played with just one or two keys) and comprised of a variety of notes regardless of the direction of the bottom movement.
Exceptions exist, though, such as the garmon, which uses a double-action movement to get the right output.
In traditional folk music, the side keyboard is often lined with one or more rows of buttons, and it is employed to play traditional folk music.
On the bass side of the keyboard, two buttons are coupled together.
One of the buttons produces the sound of a group of three major or minor notes, whilst the other buttons indicate a harmonic set of pitches or a chord structure.
There are multiple varieties of button accordions, with the diatonic accordion being the most widely used and widely available.
It is normal for the diatonic scale to have seven notes, with each note representing two notes.
This makes the button accordion well suited for fast and vigorous folk dances and traditional music.
Pros
- Due to its lesser weight and smaller size, it is more convenient to use.
- Because there are lesser keys to press, it is the best fit for a novice..
- It is ideal for traditional folk music.
- Due to the tighter spacing of the notes, performing quicker dances is highly possible..
- Some individuals find it easier to play because it only requires one movement, which is a ‘push-pull’ motion.
Cons
- Memorizing and learning the numerous buttons might be tough to master at times.
Meanwhile, McNeela Music Irish Accordion is the most incredible brand for simple, entry-level accordions.
The McNeela Music Irish Accordion is a highly tiny and lightweight diatonic accordion with a button arrangement.
What kind of accordion is the most straightforward to play?
The button accordion should be the first option for those who are just starting out, just as previously said.
When it comes to playing the piano accordion, experienced pianists or keyboard players will find it simpler to master.
The button accordion is more straightforward than the piano accordion because the buttons are more minor.
The notes are played on fewer keys instead of the piano accordion, which makes use of one key for each note.
Due to this, it is much bigger and heavier than the button accordion.
Beginners and non-professionals may be bamboozled by the many buttons available for each note on the piano accordion.
Even though the button accordion is more miniature, it has a maximum range of 64 notes that may be played, although this is not available in all button accordions.
The right hand of the piano accordion is often equipped with between 25 and 45 piano-style treble keys, with each one giving a distinct note.
Consider the Following When Choosing an Accordion
Some of the many critical factors to consider while choosing the best accordion for you are stated below:
- Accordion of certain kind
- Convenience and Portability
- Weight and size
- Cost
- Compression and reeds.
Conclusion
If you’ve learnt to play the piano beforehand, learning to play the piano accordion will be less complicated.
Once you have mastered the buttons on a button accordion, you will find it simpler to play.
Because the button accordion has tiny buttons close together, it will be easier for you to play varied intervals and ranges.
In addition, you will have more fingering possibilities than you would with a piano accordion.
The fingering possibilities on a piano accordion are rigid. You’ll have to move around more than you may like to come near to ranges comparable to the button accordion’s ranges.
A piano accordion is usually often larger and heavier than a standard accordion unless you choose a mini-accordion.
Finally, you should have some hands-on experience of both kinds of accordions to ascertain which one is ideal for what you desire.
You can get a button accordion on McNeela website online store and start playing it right away so that you can start training and growing better on a daily basis.